Casella Bagel Coffee Shop

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu

195 Reviews
Bakery, Sandwich shop
07:00 AM - 01:00 PM

About the Menu

The menu at Casella Bagel Coffee Shop offers a straightforward selection of comforting café fare, blending classic bakery treats with hearty sandwiches and satisfying sides. Whether you’re stopping by early to enjoy a warm cappuccino alongside a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel or settling in for a midday meal with a Cuban sandwich or grilled chicken club, the options are made to feel familiar and inviting.

Breakfast platters provide a filling start to the day, featuring choices like eggs any style paired with fish, steak, or meat, served alongside home fries, grits, or fries. Casual bites such as mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and buffalo chicken wings offer a relaxed, easygoing accompaniment at any time, complementing the welcoming atmosphere of this Brooklyn spot.

The menu’s approachable variety fits well with the shop’s warm and unpretentious vibe, making it a place where guests can enjoy familiar flavors without fuss. From simple sandwiches like ham and cheese to playful options like Mickey Mouse pancakes, the food invites a relaxed moment to savor everyday comfort.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 1
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 2
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 3
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 4
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 5
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu - 6

Business Menu

Breakfast Morning Starters
Bagel
US$2.25
Bagel With Butter & Jelly
US$4.00
Oatmeal
US$5.00
Muffin
US$4.25
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese
US$6.50
Bagel With Nutella & Banana
US$6.00
Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese
US$6.50
Bagel With Peanut Butter
US$4.75
Grits
US$5.00
Bagel With Butter
US$3.25
Bagel With Nutella
US$5.25
Muffin With Butter
US$4.00
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly
US$5.50
Muffin With Butter & Jelly
US$4.75
Bagel With Cream Cheese
US$4.50
Salads
Green Salad
US$5.00
Caesar Salad
US$8.00
Tuna Salad
US$8.75
Egg Salad
US$7.00
Greek Salad
US$10.00
Chef Salad
US$12.50
Chicken Salad
US$8.75
Wraps
Chicken Cheesesteak Wrap
US$13.50
California Wrap
US$16.25
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap
US$13.50
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
US$12.00
Tuna Salad Wrap
US$11.25
Vegetarian Wrap
US$12.00
Grilled Chicken Wrap
US$12.00
Grilled Chicken BLT Wrap
US$12.75
Chicken Salad Wrap
US$11.25
Breakfast Omelette Platters
Western Omelette
US$12.00
Veggie Omelette
US$11.00
Cheese Omelette
US$10.50
Low Cholesterol Omelette
US$11.50
Ham Omelette
US$10.50
Casella Omelette
US$13.00
Turkey Bacon Omelette
US$11.50
Avocado Omelette
US$12.00
Bacon Omelette
US$10.50
Plain Omelette
US$9.00
Athenian Omelette
US$15.00
Greek Omelette
US$11.50
Spanish Omelette
US$11.50
Spinach Omelette
US$10.50
Sandwiches
Genoa Salami Sandwich
US$8.00
Ham Sandwich
US$8.00
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
US$9.00
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich
US$17.00
Turkey Sandwich
US$9.00
Turkey Bacon LT Sandwich
US$8.50
Turkey Club Sandwich
US$15.00
Roast Beef Club Sandwich
US$15.00
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
US$6.00
BLT Sandwich
US$7.50
Roast Beef Sandwich
US$9.00
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich
US$10.00
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich
US$13.00
Pastrami Sandwich
US$9.00
Side Orders
Ripe Plantains
US$5.50
French Fries With Cheese
US$6.50
Green Plantains
US$5.50
French Fries
US$5.50
Home Fries
US$5.50
Beans
US$5.00
Rice
US$5.00
Buffalo Chicken Wings
US$9.75
Onion Rings
US$5.50
Mozzarella Sticks
US$8.75
Breakfast Platters
2 Eggs With Fish Flounder
US$13.25
2 Eggs With Steak
US$17.75
2 Eggs With Meat
US$10.75
2 Eggs Any Style
US$9.75
Breakfast Wraps
American Wrap
US$10.75
Low Wrap
US$11.00
Mexican Wrap
US$11.50
Florentine Wrap
US$10.75
Breakfast Griddle Originals
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs & Meat
US$13.75
French Toast With 2 Eggs & Meat
US$13.75
Pancakes With Meat
US$12.25
Plain Belgian Waffle
US$9.75
French Toast With 2 Eggs
US$11.25
Short Stack
US$7.25
Silver Dollar Pancakes
US$11.75
Pancakes With 2 Eggs
US$11.25
Pancakes With 2 Eggs & Meat
US$13.75
Plain French Toast
US$9.75
French Toast With Meat
US$12.25
Pancakes
US$9.75
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
US$11.75
Belgian Waffle With Meat
US$12.25
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs
US$11.25
Burritos
Beef Steak Burrito
US$14.50
Roast Pork Burrito
US$12.00
Grilled Chicken Burrito
US$12.00
Gyro
Chicken Gyro Sandwich
US$10.75
Chicken Gyro Platter
US$13.00
Gyro Sandwich
US$10.75
Gyro Platter
US$13.00
Hamburgers
Bacon Burger
US$8.00
Double Burger
US$9.00
Salmon Burger
US$8.75
Chicken Burger
US$10.00
Beef Burger
US$7.00
Cheeseburger
US$8.25
Casella Burger
US$11.00
Turkey Burger
US$8.75
Mushroom Burger
US$7.00
Hot Sandwiches
Roast Pork Sandwich
US$11.00
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
US$12.50
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
US$6.00
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
US$9.25
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
US$9.25
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
US$12.50
Tuna Melt Sandwich
US$10.50
Cuban Sandwich
US$13.00
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
US$13.00
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich
US$10.00
Reuben Sandwich
US$13.00
Fish Flounder Sandwich
US$11.00
Steak & Onions Sandwich
US$11.00
Meatball Sandwich
US$10.00
Salad Sandwiches
Tuna Salad Sandwich Deluxe
US$15.00
Egg Salad Sandwich Deluxe
US$15.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich
US$9.00
Egg Salad Sandwich
US$8.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich Deluxe
US$15.00
Tuna Salad Sandwich
US$9.00
Breakfast Sandwiches
1 Egg With Meat & Cheese Sandwich
US$7.50
Hungry Man
US$12.75
1 Egg Sandwich
US$4.50
1 Egg With Meat Sandwich
US$5.50
1 Egg With Cheese Sandwich
US$5.25
Beverages
Flavored Iced Coffee
US$4.50
Gatorade
US$2.50
Bottled Soda
US$3.00
Iced Coffee
US$3.50
Decaf Coffee
US$2.00
Cappuccino
US$4.50
Smart Water
US$3.00
Lipton Tea
US$2.00
Snapple
US$3.50
Simply Juice
US$2.75
Flavored Coffee
US$3.00
Canned Soda
US$2.00
Espresso
US$3.00
Milkshake
US$5.25
Coffee
US$2.00
Hot Chocolate
US$3.00
Apple & Eve Juice
US$3.00
Iced Tea
US$3.50
Bottled Water
US$1.50
Cranberry Ocean Spray
US$3.00
Lemon Pure Leaf Tea
US$3.50
Vitamin Water
US$3.50
Orange Juice
US$3.25
Herbal Tea
US$2.75
Jarritos
US$3.75
Café Mocha
US$4.75
Café Latte
US$4.50